Diversity is not Canada’s strength

20151126_sub_01_tnPrime Minister Justin Trudeau has made much of his clarion call sophomoric suggestion that “Diversity is Canada’s strength.” That’s rubbish, of course, diversity is an attribute of modern Canada, a feature, but it is hardly a strength.

Ever since classical times we have understood, almost instinctively, that unity is a strength and that diversity can ~ doesn’t always, but certainly can ~ act against national unity.

roman_lictor_with_fascesThe Etruscans appear to have given ancient Rome the symbol of the fasces lictoriae ~ the ceremonial axe strengthen by a tightly bound (unified) bundle of sticks ~ which was the ceremonial image of the power and 2011SOTUPeteSouzaWH01jpg-1840934_p9authority (imperium) of the Roman government. It was evident then, and remains so now, that unity and strength are correlated and the fasces is still used, in some of the world’s greatest democracies as a symbol of government authority and of the need for national unity.

Canada has struggled with diversity ever since 1763 when, in the Treaty of Paris, Britain agreed to protect Catholic (mainly French-Canadian) religious rights in North America. f1e669ab-93dc-4936-93c4-3aaf8b5846b8Diversity brought us to actual war in 1885 when the competing aims and ambitions of Catholic French Canadians, newly arrived, mainly Protestant, Scots immigrants and native Canadians, mainly the Métis, all collided in Manitoba and Saskatchewan. Diversity was a feature of Canada, then, and it remains one now … but it was not, then, and is not, now,  a strength.

Canada-diversity-croppedTolerance of our many and diverse customs and cultural norms is a strength … one which we have had to develop and teach in our schools, too, because we are, by choice, a diverse society. But the fact that we need to be tolerant of one another’s customs and preferences should tell us, quite clearly, that diversity is not a strength … it might even be a problem. If diversity was a strength then we wouldn’t have divisive debates about e.g. banning the niqab, we would embrace it and all that it represents ~ which is quite controversial. Diversity, which leads to identity politics, divides and, therefore, weakens us.

justin_trudeau_in_india_gi_1We need to stop the nonsense of trying to rewrite history to suit the ever so progressive attitudes of a minority ~ albeit a large one ~ of Canadians in order to achieve partisan political goals. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is ~ no surprise ~ both wrong and foolish when he says “Diversity is Canada’s strength;” it is, self-evidently, not a strength and it is, in fact and I think also self evidently, a feature or attribute of Canada, at best, and a weakness at worst.

We need to have a reasoned, rational debate about the future face of Canada … one devoid, it is to be hoped, of juveniles parroting mindless slogans.


2 thoughts on “Diversity is not Canada’s strength

  1. Great post. Something was always bothering me about the “Diversity is our Strength” bit, and the discussion of diversity vis a vis unity and tolerance sums it up nicely.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s