Exactly right

Michael-BlissProfessor Michael Bliss, a distinguished Canadian historian, is exactly right in a recent letter to the editor published in the Globe and Mail in which he says:

Re On Mali, Proceed With Extreme Caution (editorial, Jan. 24):

The best test of the justification for sending troops into areas of high risk is whether the people who propose to send them believe the cause is worthy of risking their own or their children’s lives. In the two world wars, Canada’s elites, like those of most allied countries, did not stint in enlisting and encouraging their children to enlist. How often does this happen today?

In Afghanistan, Libya, Iraq, and now perhaps Mali, the Canadian political and foreign policy establishment sent Canadian men and women into battle without risking much more than a spilled drink at the Rideau Club. Unlike the days of, say, the Spanish Civil War, sympathetic intellectuals volunteer only for CBC panel duty. If a cause isn’t worthy of risking the lives of our best and brightest, then it isn’t worthy of risking any of our lives.

To argue otherwise – isn’t risk what soldiers sign on for? – is to treat our Canadian servicemen and women as nothing more than expendable mercenaries.

Michael Bliss, historian, Toronto

Professor Bill was writing in response to an editorial in the Globe and Mail which, after noting that: any UN mission in Mali will be fraught with danger; that Canada has few (and no vital) interests in Mali; that France is there for its own, selfish, imperialist reasons; and that the whole UN peacekeeping gambit is more about partisan politics than national policy, concludes by asking: “How many young Canadians will have to die or be injured in order to fulfill this election promise?” and then suggest that “Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan should exercise real caution, rather than getting too caught up in uplifting notions.


I never expected much in the way of either intellectual or moral rigour from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and I have expressed scant regard for Harjit Sajjan, but the latter, at least, I believe must understand Professor Bliss’ last paragraph, even if it soars over the head of the former.

I, for one, think that, after they have enlisted and completed their training, the very lives and limbs and sanity of our sailors, soldiers and air force members are forfeit. They can ~ should not, but can ~ be wasted on cheap political stunts that have little or no relationship to our national interests … and that is what I believe, most firmly, that any Canadian contribution to any UN peacekeeping mission in Africa will be: a cheap, pointless, political stunt designed to accomplish nothing except to pay off some civil servants who, against all the current rules and honourable traditions of that service, actively campaigned for the Liberals in 2015.

lgen_andrew_lesliefed-lib-lt-col-harjit-sajjan-bodI wonder what the Honourable Harjit Sajjan and the Honourable Andrew Leslie, and am sure they are, both, honourable men, really think about all of this … what are they saying behind the closed doors of the cabinet room and in Liberal Party caucus meetings? Are they really content to allow this government to, in Professor Bliss’ words, “treat our Canadian servicemen and women as nothing more than expendable mercenaries?” I hope, I believe that they are better men than that.

2 thoughts on “Exactly right

  1. “How many young Canadians will have to die or be injured in order to fulfill this election promise?” or doubly, “How many young Canadians will have to die or be injured in order to let Trudeau stroke his ego in getting a UN seat. Unfortunately, for him, the US is poised to pull the plug on the UN and it has finally become a visually and physically, biased, racist and anti-semite organization. Spending blood and treasure doing anything connected to the corrupt tool of radical islam (theUN) is outside the realm of sane people, but certainly not an impossibility for inbred blue bloods we seems to favour electing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s